Home > 2026 > From the Jantarmantar to Ramlila Maidan | Radhakanta Barik

Mainstream, Vol 64 No 27, November 16, 2026

From the Jantarmantar to Ramlila Maidan | Radhakanta Barik

Monday 16 November 2026, by Radhakanta Barik

Individual freedom and knowledge go together which threatens power. This is where Modi has created godi media and servile intellectuals. With vote chori all these things are getting collapsed. Sovereignty of Knowledge has come back. The perception of people has drastically changed with the coming of international events like Lula’s victory in Brazil and students’ victory in Serbia all these have been able to have an electrifying impact over the young people of India. The struggle led by CJP added to their new consciousness that the BJP and RSS are no more a bandwagon of the Hindutva but are known as the extreme right wingers. They are for privatization of the public sectors and they help the accumulation of capital into the hands of few specifically Adani and Ambani. Coming of Secretary of State from America Marco Rubio to meet them is proving the point that Modi is their nominee.

All these are able to clear the clouds in the sky. Modi lacks the cognitive power to decide the public affairs of a nation. He works like a toy tied to strings and pulled by Ambani and Adani. They have already negotiated with the Secretary of State of America and they have reached the conclusion for selling Indian agriculture to the American companies who can dump their goods and services in India. We have to wait for the signature of Modi as guided by both the industrialists.

Modi’s jhula is ready but it is not clear when he is leaving Delhi to New York which he had a desire to get settled. It is possible as he is friend of Trump and he might fly to America. The wealthy friends he made them to leave India with their black money like Nirav Modi to Chowski etc all have defrauded the Banks of India and their money is his money. Furthermore he is busy in selling new banks which made him to make a huge money and hope that he does not carry suitcases but thali only

Lula won the majority, a socialist, a democrat; a pro people politician got back support from people. Imagine the 2014 general election when Modi a crook contested the UPA led by the Congress but he won which resulted destruction of India. People knew him but how votes polled. Today vote chori is happening. Here Lula or Rahul Gandhi supported by all needs to stop the Modi’s juggernaut.

Discussion between Bhatia and Kunal Kamra based on a discussion on the nature of Indian constitution. According to Gautam Bhatia the Indian Constitution is a pro centralised authority. But he never argues the nature of rule of the BJP under Modi and Shah. Beautiful Constitution brings people under the Preamble We the people of India with constitutional justice like equality liberty and fraternity getting demolished by a fascist party ruling over India. Whatever opposition could have come from Independent Court but the Chief Justices with immense powers like Chandrachud to Suryakanta are ready to defend the neo fascist regime of Modi
Politics of young crowd reaching the public meeting turns into a new chapter in politics of India. Crowd have oriented their actions against the neo fascist regime which is critical for saving democracy and constitution. This happened during 2004 before Vajpayee lost the general election. Two important intellectual gatherings happened in the city of Delhi. One where the Young historian Romila Thapar spoke in FICCI auditorium and in another Rajendra Yadav the leading Hindi writer cum editor of Hansa spoke in Ghalib Bhawan where huge gathering took place. In both of these meetings I was there and I spoke out that things were going against the Vajpayee regime. This got resulted in the victory of UPA where the Congress and left parties all joined together. Today the situation is changing and the intellectual environment has completely changed. On 25th of October Prof Romila Thapar spoke on the occasion of Comrade Sitaram Yechury memorial lecture. There was a huge gathering of young people which explains the new trend is growing in Indian politics. The protest movement of youths and CJP all combined together already eroded the legal and constitutional basis of the Modi regime. It is matter of time that he is losing power to united front led by the Congress and left. Romila Thapar is the major critic of Hindutva politics and their perception of history writing. In her talk she questioned the Hindutva way of looking at Indian history which has similarity with the colonial historiography.

Modi and the BJP government of the state of Odisha are interested to hand over the power of mining to Adani which is looking on the paper is an easy thing but it is a difficult thing as the trajectory of history tells us that similar situation happened to Vedant twenty years back when Naveen Patnaik was the chief minister whose government wanted to hand over the mountains and forests of the tribal community to Vedant and the richest mining owner from London. He is paying bribe to the BJP with Adani to occupy the forests and mountains for mining works . It is impossible to get there as tribals are ready to die for their land water and jungle. It is not interested to support them. The BJP government has very poor percentages of votes. The party is ruling by manipulating the votes which has been found by the Biju Janata Dal and handed over it to the ECI and but no action has been taken yet. Patnaik and the Congress leaders and the CPI CPM and CPML are going to fight together. It is almost impossible. Furthermore, the deaths and violence will produce the international news. In the past the Supreme Court intervened on behalf of the working of PESA and imagines the whole election of so many villages happened under the supervision of a District Session Judge. This resulted in stay of the whole case. Modi thinks of Odiyas are not fighting the battle but his perception is wrong. They caught him red handed while taking the gold from the temple of Jagannath and today people will not allow the handing over the jungle and mountains and earth of people to the Adani and Vedanta

Shri Malikarjun Kharge the President of Congress Party uses a strong statement like " Modi’s Bapa jayega" or Modi’s father is going to leave the chair" This is the language used in rural India when a powerful person leaves the chair or leaving the chair. Then the opponents use the strong words which has nothing against the Parliamentary language. It is a part of the public discourse when the big tall tree is either falling or going to fall. This explains the strength of the opposition unity that are going to meet with its supporters on 1st November in opposition to Gyanesh Kumar. The power balance has shifted towards the opposition unity and going to reflect on the coming protest to be held on 1st November .

Politics is changing. Modi and Shah are unable to comprehend it. Victory of Lula despite Trump’ s support for the opponent did not work. Politics in India is changing fast. Modi’s visit to Banaras did not draw any crowd. Politics of various groups for the last three months has pushed the public against them. This resulted in agreement with the demands of students of JNU Jamie and Aligarh. 1st November is going to draw 10 lakhs to the demonstration against Gyanesh Kumar. Government is nervous and may accept the resignation of Gyanesh Kumar on any day.

Comrade Lula of Brazil lost in the first round of election against his opponent’s family as his main opponent Bolsonaro who is in jail for 21 years and his family members contested against Lula and in the first round they had the higher percentages of votes but in the second round of election Lula’s appeal reached the poor tribals and working class who voted for him and he won the election. One feels safe in his hands. Modi won 12 years back and he did not win Bengal and Odisha but after winning the elections here Modi have started attacking the mountains and forests and cultural capital of these states. Can we imagine this that the attacks on book stalls in Bengal had a catastrophic impact on the Bengal psychic of people? By selling mountains and forests to Adani the state of Odisha including the tribals are mourning for days and many of them are in jail.

Our problems to realize our dreams of having a progressive regime we faces challenges: It is getting pointed out by the slogan on Azadi ham le kar rahenge which indicate the obstacles on the path such as the most important is this that discrimination among our people against Dalits and tribals and Muslims. Can we recover it and then come we have to come out of hunger which is another obstacle which is not there in Brazil. So many obstacles are on the path of realizing the freedom from these tentacles hanging over us. It is possible but Modi regime twists the facts and destroys the Mosque to create polarization between Muslims and Hindus. His people get involved in rapes of Dalit women and get saved by manipulating the judges and police men. This may not be there in Brazil but despite the path of united front struggle against Vote Chori and demand for removal of Gyanesh Kumar brings unity among people to achieve the target.

In Brazil Bolsonaro the extreme right winger like Modi lost to Lula in a fairer election. In a fair election where Gyanesh Kumar will not be there Modi will surely lose.

I was listening to Neha Bora in an interview with Karan Thapar in Wire and she has clarity about the actions she has taken for last two months in the various protests against the Modi regime. But the other part of her story is this that she is being followed by the plain clothes women police where she is going and it is scary. Today it is undeclared emergency of Modi Shah Regime and we were students of the same university of Neha used to study during 1970s and we confronted the declared emergency and the police men picked up from our hostel rooms in the morning to the police station of Hauz Khas. After some hours we got released except four or five were taken to Tihar jail. But no one was beaten or harassed by police men. Today those participating in the protests are getting beaten and bruised and detained. They are being branded as anarchists but we used to be called by the Police Commissioner in the police station: Do you want to be a political leader then we will send you to the jail? Our leader was Sitaram Yechury who got elected three times by opposing Mrs Indira Gandhi and opposed the emergency. Today Neha Bora is emerging as the leader students and mass movements in India is confronting the neo fascist regime which is cruel and brutal.

It is strange but true that Hindutva has an ugly face. Those who stood in front of the Mandir Marg police station are the RSS activists who abused Neha Bora while she entered the police station. Police and RSS goons stood together against her on the streets. They have no right to abuse Neha, they need to be punished by the law of land. Three Nehas are fighting their battles and each takes up the challenge to speak out. Neha Bora challenged the state by not signing the bond with the state. She shows bravery towards common people by not bowing down the state. The other Neha an Ambedkarite speaking out against Modi and Shah bluntly that they have stolen votes of the ordinary citizens. The other Neha making mimicry against Modi and Shah branded by the powerful as a prostitute and she replied them in bluntly which made them to apologise to her? All three are fighting a battle against the state of Modi and Shah.

Modi is some strange uncouth monster. After selling all public sectors to his friends Ambani and Adani now they’re busy selling the gold and silver from temples of India. The Secretary of the American state met Ambani and Adani in their backyard not in Delhi. Modi wants to remain in power by doing vote chori shamelessly. He could convince the Railway police force not to come by the train to Godhra by which it could be burnt. He allowed the dead bodies to be carried to Ahemdabad despite the opposition of senior police officers and the Home Minister Pande. This resulted in creating large scale riots which resulted in the coming of Modi to power in Gujarat. Today in Delhi he uses all immoral means to remain in power. No public morality with him.

Indian middle class played a critical role on three occasions. First using their intelligence and imagination in making the Constitution of India. It is a bold step announcing that " we the people of India " which is a marvelous text. In rural society each family is recognized by his clan or caste or class but in urban society lanes are recognized by the nature of people living in the lane. But creating a public statement that we the people of India is the product of fertile imagination of the class. Accepting the reservation for SC and ST turns into another bold statement as the upper caste urban middle class were members of the Constituent assembly speaking for long term social change in the society. The third one is this that accepting the Hindu Marriage Act and Civil Marriage act are two bold statements despite they are the propertied people knowing well that they will lose their property by denying their sons as the inheritors of property. Allowing their daughters is to marry in any community turns into a bold statement. For a long time the middle class remained silent and they have come to the streets for saying that they do not agree with the Vote chori. Their voting right is not snatched but they speak for people of India another bold statement. When they speak out from the streets turn out to be aesthetically formulated one. Middle class carry an aesthetic tradition with their imagination. Middle class are not thinking in a binary way. This is the Puja time and easy to think in the language of Ram vs Ravana. But they decry it that Ravana is an intellectual and well-read person whereas Modi has no education. This allows imagination to flow like a river.

Hindutva is a corrupt and vile system. They see the regeneration of caste hierarchy. They got the support from the stupidity of the high castes. They reinvented Ram and made him a joker by pulling him into communal and caste politics. They see the corrupt system helping them to realist power. They rigged the Evm to come to power. Now they have gone down to vote chori by manipulating the voters list. In the process they are caught red handed. They want to steal the wealth of the nation and hand it over to Adani Ambani. Trump and Epstein shape their dirty persona. They chose corrupt bureaucrats judges and police men supported criminals of the country to rule. There is no hope with public institutions and only hope from the streets. Street politics has aesthetics, intelligence and imagination. It’s the best of India and the worst of India. The way protest movements have been organized by the Gen Z in India which is totally peaceful whereas the protest movements in Europe are turning violent. Indian state under Modi and Shah are turning violent by bringing 50 thousand police men to Delhi and banning the protest site. Despite those restrictions they move in a Gandhian manner as they think Gandhi is the guide and philosopher of our times. This is being taken by these rulers as weakness of the movement which is not true. Politics is like an Ocean but waves are coming and touching the shores but storms can grow into cyclonic wind which can blow the tents pitched on the shore and the state needs to look at these tents and which may fly by the wind.
Street politics is going to be permanent phenomena as the fascists rule over India. Democrats have to organised on their level and they need to come to the streets in the defence of democracy. It is "we the people of India ’ standing on the streets of Delhi Calcutta and Banglore to Hyderabad etc. The movement cannot be stopped and it is going to grow stronger and stronger against fascist regime based on Vote chori. Today in Delhi various left students and academia and democratic individuals like retired judges and lawyers are on the streets. Modi may not agree with them and brand them as Dimagi naxal but they have taken over the streets and there is no space for the RSS and BJP on the streets of India. They are going to be confined to the barracks of the fascists. Let us celebrate the mass protests against fascists.

Modi and Shah and Bhagwat find the language of breaking Masjid to create communal polarisation to save themselves in power which has paid them huge money. RSS headquarter in Delhi costing 150 crores speaking about it. Bhagwat is moving with high security speaks of his arrogance in power. Modi uses language of hatred day in and day out for polarization of Hindu Muslims. Shah is interested in making money as his son does not know ABC of cricket but the chairman for earning huge money. While protests are going on in the various parts of the country and American Secretary of State which is next to President Trump has been doing business in Gujarat. This is like while bombardment of Iraq was going on the Oil business was going on. It is happening in India that business men like Adani is sitting in Odisha to destroy the mountains of the state where people live in there. Cruel and inhuman treatment both associated with Modi and Shah. Politics of Gen Z in India has no similarities of Nepal or Bangladesh which I followed and wrote some articles on Nepal politics of that time and I used to argue that it is wrong to ignore the contributions made by the left parties in Nepal to bring democracy in the country ruled by the Monarchy. It turned into a secular state. In India the youths wings of the left parties and Congress and Ambedakarites are active in the protest movement and the major opposition party the Congress is standing with them. There the issue corruption turned into a challenge and here the vote chori as the challenge and deletion of 13 crores of voters is the issues. Both are different and furthermore the issue of Universal adult franchise is the basis of democracy which getting ignored by Modi Shah Regime and supported by the RSS. We are different in politics of the youth movement here.

The protest movement is going to fail or succeed is not the question but the point is this that movement has entered into public imagination that Modi government is illegal based on vote chori done in 2024 general election and assembly elections held afterwards. This is the key point of the movements organised by Gen Z on the streets of India. For the first time one looks at the streets as very friendly ones for us and provides space for conversations which used to happen during the national movement in India. Street provides space for the film makers to choreograph their songs on the streets. Looking at the films made by Raj Kapoor and film songs of his famous films is to prove the point. Today the youngsters have invented the space of street into mapping of politics and culture of our times.

RSS looks like a spoiled boy without any critical comments by Bhagwat on his annual lecture on Dasahara . Claiming it stands of unity of people is a big joke. They trained cow vigilante in Teenmurti to attack the Muslims. After training these bald headed criminals by the RSS leaders and a lady police officer they went on a series of killing innocent Muslims. Does it serve unity or the state has not punished these criminals. 12 years of staying in power and position they have vested interest in continuing of Modi rule. It resulted in crimes and allowed goons to attack the demonstration. They are behaving like the SS of Hitler. Modi speaking in the name of Ramrajya is a big laughter as Modi Yogi has stolen from the Ram temple. Now they have been involved in the vote chori. They are selling the nation to Adani Ambani and Trump. He is enjoying power with wealth plus women.

The way Delhi police reacting to the protest against the CEC and its undemocratic approach to deletion and addition of voters to the list of voters creates doubts regarding the handling of police force. As it is a law and order problem not of public order then how they ordered the closure of the Metro and arresting people from the trains all these turn into define the political regime of Modi Shah who is working as a neo fascist regime. Look at the 2011 Anna movement but no police action against the demonstrators or no closure of the metro or arrests from the train. The same situation prevailed during 1974 students protest led by JP which got controlled by the police. Furthermore there was always communication between the political executive and demonstrates which is not happening today. They have no reading of Gandhi who told before the Independence that the democratic government will allow bigger movements and no police action. They follow the ideas of Savarkar and Godse who supported violence and Godse killed Gandhi who pleaded for peaceful protest. The Delhi police have no planning to handle the protest of students. Furthermore it is wrong to declare the Jantar Mantar site as illegal place of congregation. In the world in democratic regimes where protest sites have not changed and here it has changed because of political reasons rather than law and order point of view. The protests are going to increase unless the government of today remove the Gynaesh Kumar as the CEC and bring back the voters list before 2019.

Politics of SIR constructed by the ECI has been discussed by the public. The Supreme Court has taken a different stand for the first time today. It used to side with the ECI regarding the removal of voters under the SIR which happened in Bihar and Bengal. For the first time SC is adding to a dimension to the whole gamut of activities made by the ECI. Street protests impinges the proceedings of the court which has reflected today but there is no judgement but these are verbal statements regarding the form 6 which meant for new voters, form 7 regarding the deletion of the voters and Form 8 making minor changes. Regarding the SIR worked out in Bihar as Justice Bagchi says that it is not final which indicates that the whole things can be reviewed by the Court. But the court would have taken a decision regarding the SIR which is the bone of contention and till today knowing well the bench of three judges headed by the Chief Justice of India needs to take a quick decision for bringing peace and justice.

After participating in the rally organised by the India alliance in the Ramlila Maidan my spirit got lifted and I feel excited and energetic and hoping to write something beautifully in favour of the crowd and its role in history. They have a single orientation like the changing the government of Modi and Shah which have come to power with the help of vote chori. This is an established fact now. Despite the Maidan is in bad shape and full of mud and water but crowd standing and sitting there. Some important slogans were there: fascism in Modi politics which brings out the truth regarding the character of the present government. Collective voice of people of India is getting articulated in a bold and lucid manner.

Impressive rally is telling that there is no public support for the Modi Shah but they rule with the help of the vote chori. Vote Chori has brought a false image of Modi who is taken as the only leader of the India. Then he combines the criminals and corrupt and communalism into one which is ruling today. In each policy there is a scam which explains the Modi stands for corrupt practices in India which had never happened. This rally will teach a lesson that once they lose power the nation will investigate into their corrupt practices and collect the money they have stolen.

Rally in Ramlila Maidan stands as a sign of good fortune be it 1974 rally addressed by JP or hunger strike led by Anna Hazare all these augured political changes which are bad or good needs be evaluated. This rally by all India Alliance is biggest and genuine and intentionally saving democracy in India. This rally got the crowd of millions of young crowd addressed by all the top leaders belonging to Opposition and one of them were Neha Bora who turned into another leader who addressed the crowd. She claims that in the history of democracy the Modi regime supported by the ECI of Gynenesh Kumar is going to be put into dustbin. Rahul Gandhi is clear that Modi Shah and Gyanesh Kumar all three will be punished by the Indian people. It looks like the November rally is auguring well and the news of political change has reached various corners of the country and people are getting ready to vote Modi out of power. Akhilesh Yadav spoke out the changes coming in the biggest state of India that is UP which gave Modi and Yogi. If the election is going be held without Gyanesh Kumar and based on ballot papers the dream is going to be real soon. The crowd is young below fifty and most of them are beedi smoker which indicate that they are closely associated with popular culture of India people. They are not fashionable like other political leaders of the BJP and RSS who speak only lies and speak non sense. These energetic leaders with bubbling with energies and burning eyes will bring changes in Indian politics.

The opposition unity creates a motivating political moment for the public and public are ready to discuss the issues related to the vote chori. All these issues got a grandiose posture in the mock parliament which impeaches the Chief Election Commissioner. The leaders and lawyers and students leaders all spoke in a collective spirit that the Gyanesh Kumar is at fault. This is possible because of Modi and Shah who provide him the defense mechanism to get involved in removal of 13 crores of voters from the voters list. Some of them were present in the rally speaking out with proofs that they voted in the last election but today their names have vanished. Indian public is learning at a faster pace regarding the complexities of voters list. Today politics is going beyond Modi and Shah and the issues of unemployment and acquisition of the mountains and forests and seas and air in the hands of Adani and Ambani have alienated people at grass roots level. Tribals of Odisha are on a mood to fight for their livelihoods by maintaining the control over the mountains and forests. People in Chhattisgarh are fighting the same battle in different way. Battles in Maharashtra over the famine issues and urban people fighting their issues related unemployment and price rice all combined create bleak picture for Modi regime.

Today Modi cannot speak lies to cajole public mood and the government cannot deliver the goods and services to public because they lack the capacity because of high level of corruption in each level of administration. Peasantry is not getting fertilizer at due price or examinations for the jobs getting leaked out to keep the unemployed as unemployed forever. Educational level is declining at faster rate keeping students alienated and disillusioned. They are ready to jump into politics partly the CJP encouraged them come to the streets and they are not ready to go back to the barracks. They are joining the unemployed army to side with oppositional politics for time being. Political cyclone is coming up in UP assembly election which is the corner stone of the Hindutva project which can prove the point that they have lost the support base. Religion is no more a political factor after the chori in Ram Mandir turned into a public issue. Once temple politics is pushed back then politics of India is going to be played on the rational way and public actions need to be supported by the reasons not faith.