I was there, like many other reporters covering the political beats, in the Central Hall when Sonia Gandhi resolutely declined to wear the mantle of Prime Ministership of India while the Congress leaders and I remember distinctly Mani Shankar Aiyar rushed to the podium to plead with her to reconsider her decision. But she had none of it. And like many of my like minded friends there, frankly, I was disappointed.
Next day I was enjoying an afternoon lunch at the Press Club in between my running around to gather news that I saw on the strap line of one of the news channels, I don’t remember which, that Dr Manmohan Singh had been chosen and will be the next Prime Minister of India. That upset me even more because in my perception Dr Manmohan Singh represented the market forces and I considered Sonia led Congress and other anti BJP/NDA forces as opposed to blind liberalisation and marketisation, causing distress most of all, to the rural poor.
But over the years I changed my mind and appreciated Sonia’s decision to choose none other than Dr Manmohan Singh to lead the country in that crisis ridden ‘Shining India’, Never mind that the much- admired Pranab Mukherjee, felt cheated for he felt entitled to assume that office. This reminds me of Morarji Desai, who long before Pandit Jawahar Lal Nehru died felt entitled to succeed him as India’s Prime Minister and if he was bypassed the first time by Lal Bahadur Shastri, he would have none of it the second upon Shastriji’s untimely death when he contested in the Congress Parliamentary Party (CPP) and lost convincingly to a young Indira Gandhi, whom he considered not competent enough to occupy that chair rightfully belonging to him and in fact told that Italian journalist Oriano Fallaci the she (Indira) would be thrown on the heap of garbage.
I say this because we the people of this sub-continent be it Indians or Pakistanis or even Bangladeshis, we are still patriarchal and feel cheated if a woman leads the country, as the killing of Indira, Benazir Bhutto in Pakistan and near killing of Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh proved amply. And a sixth sense told Sonia that the country could not progress on the road to development, were she to accept that offer. Already soon, after the results came for the 14th Lok Sabha, my dear editor those days M.J. Akbar was in a state of shock with a frown on his face, having put all his eggs in Advani’s basket. Sushma Swaraj immediately announced her intent to leave her hair open and sleep on the floor like Rani Kekai and Uma Bharti going one step further declared she would go for a head shave. Actually, the then Deputy Prime Minister L.K. Advani had created such mirage of ‘Shining India’ that mesmerised all Sonia haters, including many who today swear they did not really hate Sonia, despite spewing venom all the time.
Anand Sahay in The Wire has upheld Sonia’s choice of Manmohan Singh citing two very significant aspects of Dr Singh’s personality—one his image of being not personally corrupt in spite of favouring market forces as a matter of policy and second, his being a renowned economist, whom even the then US President Barrack Obama consulted on weighty economic issues. No doubt Dr Singh possessed both of these qualities and perhaps that is the reason Manmohan Singh government chose A.K. Antony to head India’s Defence ministry gain for his clean image, remembering how the Opposition kept pulling out the ‘Bofors’ rabbit from its hat anytime they saw the Congress political graph climbing up.
Again, I remember, in the runup to the 2009 general elections when the Left had deserted and the Congress seemed vulnerable, putting Advani in high spirits of finally grabbing that elusive PM chair, he sent one day my former editor Arun Shourie to address the daily press briefing at 11, Ashoka Road, where he tried pinning Bofors once again on Sonia. I couldn’t resist the temptation and reminded him in that press conference, with my fellow comrade journalist Neena Vyas by my side, “Mr Shourie but your fellow BJP MP and former minister Ram Jethmalani has spoken in the Rajya Sabha to bury the Bofors ghost, because whatever monetary loss the Government may have incurred, the Hindujas were ready to make up.” And I was not making it up. It was the government of Narasimha Rao those days and Madhav Sinh Solanki was then our External Affairs Minister, the BJP again tried to rake up Bofors when Jethmalani rose to contradict his own party. Shourie said, ‘Faraz is a very dear friend, but I don’t know what is he talking about.” I am sure he very well knew but never mind. Even today the Indian Express tried to dig out the Bofors ghost and Ottavio Quattroci from their respective graves. They do it every time they see Sonia’s popularity rising.
But let us return to Dr Singh and to Sonia deciding to hand over the command of the UPA government to him and not to Pranab Mukherjee. Because of two additional factors not mentioned even by Anand Sahay. One because he was from a minority community and a Sikh at that. The Army action at the Golden Temple in Amritsar in June 1984 had hurt the Sikh psyche so badly that they all forgot how Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale went about killing innocent Hindus and even police officers because of the licence issued to him by Giani Zail Singh and implicitly Indira Gandhi as well.
But the massacre of poor Sikhs in Delhi under the watchful eyes of the then Union Home Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao and Haryana chief minister Bhajan Lal was no answer to either the Hindu killings in Punjab nor of Mrs Gandhi’s assassination by her two Sikh bodyguards. That was criminal and those responsible surely needed to be punished. But only those and all those who were actually involved. I was in Chandigarh then. But my younger brother Dr Cameron Ahmad and my dear friend now dead Zafar Agha on a motorcycle accompanied by Gauhar Raza and his elder brother Ahma Raza on a scooter, all three from IIT Delhi, roamed the city those horrible days and my brother spotted some well-known faces of ABVP from Delhi University leading marauding mobs in South Delhi. So surely Congressmen were there but so were others. And don’t forget Nanaji Deshmukh wrote a centre page article in the Indian Express justifying the “retaliation.” In any case neither Sonia nor her two children can be held responsible for those events. And as for Rajiv, if he had his way Punjab problem would have been solved much, much before the necessity of Operation Blue Star, if you read Mark Tully and Satish Jacob’s book Amritsar: Mrs Gandhi’s Last Battle. And Rajiv did sign the accord with Sant Harchand Singh Longowal and then two successive bloodless operations Black Thunder were successfully launched.
So even in the Congress party none but Sonia could have imagined and then decided to choose Dr Manmohan Singh. If the likes of Advani hated a Sikh leading India to prosperity without tom tomming ‘Shining India’ so be it. One more reason the Sanghis hated the guts of Sonia and Manmohan were because both have or had proved to be committed secularists. Remember how when Manmohan Singh met Pakistan Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani between the Non-aligned meet at Sharm-el-Sheikh and issued a joint statement in July, 2009, soon after Dr Singh’s second term commenced, the then ex foreign minister in the NDA government Yashwant Sinha attacked Dr Singh viciously in the Lok Sabha over meeting the Pakistani Prime Minister knowing full well that the Mumbai attack operation was launched in November 2008 by those terrorists who resented a People’s Party government ruling Pakistan, never mind that that government was weak and powerless. But why was it such ‘Sharm (shame)’ for Dr Manmohan Singh? Sadly, no Congressman rose in defence of Dr Singh, not even from the Left and other secular parties.
Two remarkable things about Dr Singh, one that he was a committed secularist to the core and as a corollary he was keen to resolve the Kashmir problem also peacefully. The Sanghis would have none of that and so they condemned him as powerless. But those in the know, know very well that both Sonia and even Pranabda were opposed to breaking off from the Left, opposed to the Civil Nuclear deal with the US. But Dr Singh firmly stood his ground, and jettisoned the Left support. In the end it only destroyed the Left. As for the defeat of the Congress and its allies in 2014, that’s a story to be told another day for even Anna Hazare is now swearing he is no longer a RSS puppet.
Mainstream Weekly