At a time when a deep sense of anguish is prevailing across the Arab world over Israel’s hegemonic design and its ruthless policies, a manifesto recently released by the Arab intellectuals once again highlights the subservient nature of the Arab ruling elite in confronting Israel. It resonates the public sentiments and thereby brings into focus the disconnect between the Arab street and self-serving undemocratic regimes in the region. The Manifesto has been signed by 309 intellectuals from the Arab world (Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Palestine, Syria, Morocco, Qatar, Sudan, Libya, Western Sahara, and Mauritania ) and the diaspora ( France, Spain, Italy, Canada, the US, Sweden, Netherlands, Switzerland, Austria, South Africa, and El Salvador). The signatories include academics, artists, activists, lawyers, feminists, women networks, and human rights groups. They represent the most progressive, pro-people and enlightened segment of the Arab society. They “denounce the complicity” of a section of the Arab political, economic and intellectual elites who collaborate with the “treacherous” regimes which are under the control of and “serve their Western masters”.
The context
Since 07 October 2023, Israel is engaged in multiple wars against the Arab people in pursuance of its Zionist project: the so-called Greater Israel. In Gaza, it is carrying out a live-streamed genocide with impunity; in the West Bank, its forces are implementing a silent ethnic cleansing through land grabbing, fast-paced settlement building which includes the planned E-1 project, house demolition and state-sponsored violent settler attacks ; in Lebanon, the IDF is committing war crimes while occupying more and more territory in the South under the guise of establishing a “security” zone ; and in Syria, the Israeli forces have established a permanent presence beyond the occupied Golan Height by entering the UN-patrolled buffer zone after the downfall of the Assad regime. Before the elections, the Israeli defence minister boastfully asserted that Israel is determined to keep its troops in in the “security zones” it has created within Lebanon, Syria, and Gaza. These acts of aggression are always justified in the name of self-defence, as if “conquest is synonymous with self-defence”. Iraq, Sudan and Yemen too are embroiled in conflicts of a different nature. Simply put, the region is under the grip of the “Israeli-western war-machine”. That these multiple operations are continuing despite Us-mediated peace deals and ceasefires point towards a larger game plan: an imperialist –Zionist deign to subjugate the Arab people and take control of their resources by crushing any sign of resistance. It will not make much difference even if there is a change of government in Israel. Instead of supporting people’s resistance against the Zionist aggression, the Arab leaders are busy in making deals with Israel to please the US for their own regime security. It is against the backdrop of such a humiliating national scene and a grave security environment in the Arab world that the Manifesto was released to reclaim the voice of the Arab street against occupation and foreign domination, and reassert their legitimate right to national self-determination.
Message
In a befitting and bold preface, the Manifesto begins with few lines from the writings of Abu el-Kacem Chebbi :
“When one day the people wills to liveFate itself must answer that callThe night must surely fade awayThe chains must surely break and fall”
Chebbi was a celebrated young Tunisian poet of early twentieth century, whose verses resonated through the voice of the youth and the spirit of resistance against the French colonial rule. The above lines are from his most famous poem “To the Tyrants of the World”. These lines became “an anthem for liberation movements across the Arab world”. The Tunisian protesters recited these very lines during the Arab Spring which inspired and ignited the demand for democracy, freedom and justice across the region.
Thematically, the Manifesto at the beginning seeks to rekindle the collective memory and conscience of the Arab world by reminding its people the long history of colonialism, imperialism and Zionism and their manouvres to fragment, exploit and subjugate the region by using the primordial fault lines of the complex societies. From the Berlin Congress (1878), to the Sykes-Picot agreement (1916 )and the Balfour Declaration(1917), to the façade of the mandate system , the same imperialist logic was at work which got further strengthened when Zionism became a tool of imperialism resulting in nearly two centuries of “perpetual war, blockade, and destruction” in the Arab world. The Manifesto rightly sees the hijacking of the Arab Spring, the Abraham Accords, and the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC) project as an alternative to the Chinese Silk Road, as part a “new imperial moment” aimed at protecting American hegemony in the region through Israel acting as the “indispensable geographic hub”. The signatories, as “heirs” to a long history of Arab peoples’ resistance against colonialism, Zionism and imperialism firmly assert the following. First, they unequivocally reject the “sham peace and any form of normalization” with Israel which they consider “the enemy state”. Such strong opposition to the normalization process between the Arab states and Israel flow from harsh lessons after the Oslo and Abraham Accords which merely consolidated Israeli hegemony and further fragmentation in the region. The latter were certainly against the will of the people as opinion polls had shown then. They demand the “termination of all normalization agreements” which are basically imposed by Western imperialism and concluded under military and economic pressure in “contempt of the sacrifices “of the Arab people. Second, they denounce Israel’s ongoing “predatory and expansionist” settler-colonial project aimed at establishing a “Greater Israel” which forms the “strategic core of Western imperialism” and has become more evident now than ever before. Israeli ministers openly called for new settlements in south Lebanon after occupying till the Litani River, and Syria and Gaza. No agreement can be reached with Israel until the liberation of all occupied land and recognizing the Palestinian refugees’ “right to return”. Third, the Manifesto affirms the Arab peoples’ right to self-determination as an “inalienable principle” as per the UN Charter and international law. The Palestinians, the Lebanese and all Arab peoples, who confront the “same choice between genocide and dignity” must exercise this right. The Arabs have every right to wage armed struggle against “colonial domination and foreign occupation”. Fourth, they reject the “purely symbolic” international solidarity, at the government level, with the Arab people who are fighting against the imperialist order and the oppressive structure it produces. Solidarity that costs nothing and commits nothing is meaningless. Supporting an occupied people that does not bother the occupier is to “support their suffering, not their liberation”. They call for real action by “whatever means” to emancipate the occupied people which may have a political price. Britain, France, Canada and some other European countries have shown the way, howsoever limited that may be. Finally, the Arab intellectuals emphasize their responsibility echoing the stand taken by Ghassan Kanfani and Bassel Al-Araj: in colonized and foreign dominated societies, intellectuals have a bounden duty to stand by peoples’ revolt against the colonizer by supporting “all forms of resistance” wholeheartedly and without taking refuge “in a facade of neutrality” that merely serves the interest of the oppressor.
Total Liberation
The demand is “total liberation and full sovereignty” over the Arab lands, resources, and modes of production. At a time when the destiny of the Arab region and its proud people is being shaped by the imperialist-Zionist forces, remaining silent would tantamount to “abdication”, even complicity. Given the “ region’s DNA” of resistance, the signatories firmly believe that Palestine will be free from the Zionist-imperialist clutches in the same way Algeria became free from 132 years of brutal French colonial rule, and no “collaborationist regime can survive” in the face of the Arab people’s “aspirations for emancipation”. Perhaps, it is a moment of reckoning for the Arab regimes.
(Bansidhar Pradhan was Professor at Centre for West Asian Studies,SIS, JNU)
Mainstream Weekly