Home > 2026 > Garment workers and Provident Fund: Caught between future security vs (…)

Mainstream, Vol 64 No 27, November 16, 2026

Garment workers and Provident Fund: Caught between future security vs present precarity

Monday 16 November 2026

by Renuka Phadnis

Garment workers in Karnataka want immediate and full withdrawal of their Provident Fund (PF) post employment as they see it as a financial safety net for emergencies rather than post-retirement security. Because PF contributions are directly determined by wage levels, labour representatives and authorities contend that worker demands must prioritize enforcement of government benchmarks on minimum wages.

During the first two weeks of October, 2026, garment workers in Bengaluru and other Karnataka cities such as Tumakuru, Maddur, Tiptur, Hubballi, Haveri and Shivamogga held dharnas protesting changes to the rules governing access to the Provident Fund (PF) and Employees Pension Scheme (EPS). Under the amended rules, notified on June 29, 2026, workers must wait 12 months after leaving employment to claim PF and 36 months to claim EPS. The PF amount must also be claimed in parts, with 75 per cent released first and the remaining balance after a year.

Consequent to those demonstrations, one prominent union leader indicated that workers intend to resume strike actions effective November 9.

PF or wages

The government attributes the change in PF withdrawal regulations to reorganising the social security scheme for workers to address evolving demographic and ageing patterns. The objective is to provide post-retirement financial security to garment workers, a majority of whom are women. According to Navendu Rai, Regional PF Commissioner-I, EPFO (a statutory body under the Ministry of Labour and Employment, Government of India, which implements PF and EPS laws), PF was conceptualised as a long-term savings mechanism. It is neither charity nor deferred pay by the employer. It is a rights-based fund to which workers are entitled. It ensures that savings accumulated during working years become income support when earning ability declines.

As basic wages determine PF contribution, the threshold of government-fixed minimum wage influences calculations. A lower basic wage reduces both the employee’s and the employer’s PF contributions. Urging workers to remain within the PF net, Mr Rai said, "Workers have a right to be angry. But the issue is not PF but minimum wages. The fight is with minimum wages. PF is based on wages actually drawn."

Leaders of two trade organisations—the All India Trade Union Congress (AITUC) and the Garment Labour Union (GLU)—along with Munnade, a social organization led by former women garment workers, concur with the government’s rationale that the issue of withdrawing PF is intrinsically linked to the payment of minimum wages.

Union efforts to dissuade workers from prematurely liquidating their PF assets during periods of immediate financial distress is challenging. The disconnect was exemplified when a worker openly expressed scepticism and questioned a union leader’s interests following explanations on long-term security.

A woman garment worker from Bihar working in Bengaluru said, "If I resign, I want my full PF amount in two months. Just reverse to the old rules for getting PF."

According to Rukmini V. P., President and Co-Founder of GLU , workers want a reversal to the earlier rules because their low wages force them to claim PF. After working for five years, many leave their jobs, withdraw PF and stop working.

Minimum wages

Agreeing that the new changes in PF access were aimed at providing financial security, Professor Babu Mathew, State President for Karnataka, All India Trade Union Congress (AITUC) and Visiting Faculty at National Law School of India University (NLSIU), said that workers should restrain themselves from withdrawing PF for reasons such as medical expenses. He said, "If you fall ill, you should use ESI (Employees State Insurance), not PF." He advised workers to focus on securing the minimum wages fixed by the government. "We should try to reach there," he said.

Lifespan and security

"Opting out of PF is dangerous," says Professor Mohan Mani, Visiting Fellow, Centre for Labour, NLSIU. Garment industries cite factors such as the competitiveness of being part of a global supply chain for not paying government-fixed minimum wages. However, the garment sector is seeing increasing profit margins, and global competition cannot continue to be used as a reason to keep workers’ wages low. He thinks that securing minimum wages for garment workers on par with workers of other industries will be a struggle for unions. "This is not an issue that will get resolved immediately," he said. Another factor working against workers is their high turnover, particularly among migrant workers. Frequently, companies pay them full salaries but without PF deductions.

In response to workers’ views that they could die early and leave their children grappling with the bureaucracy of accessing their PF, Mr Rai said, "People don’t die early." Quoting from the Sample Registration System (SRS) Based Abridged Life Tables 2020-24 of the Office of the Registrar General and Census Commissioner, India, he noted that life expectancy at the national level for men and women has been estimated at 68.7 years and 72.8 years, respectively.

Immediate funds paramount to future security

Union leaders said it would be difficult to convince workers about PF as a fund for their senior years. Ms Rukmini maintained that GLU’s stand is clear—the PF law is good. It is a crucial fund for the garment workers’ future that should be saved. But workers point out that their wages are very low and that they cannot wait that long. "We are trying to convince many of them. But none of the workers is ready to accept it," she said.

She observed that collective labour resistance to these policy changes remains concentrated within the garment sector due to depressed wages. She emphasized that a monthly income of Rs 13,000 per month presents a severe barrier to basic material survival within an urban economy considering the cost of living in Bengaluru.

Workers also feel that the Central and State governments should have consulted them, since changes to the law directly affect their livelihoods. Ms Rukmini said, "They must call unions and see whether that law will help the workers or create problems. If they suddenly start implementing a new law, that is very wrong, we feel."

Munnade, led by former women garment workers, has been actively engaging with workers on the importance of preserving PF savings for long-term financial security. Yashodhamma P. H., Executive-Director and General Secretary of Munnade Social Organization, said that while PF is a worker’s right and earns interest, the combination of low wages and high living costs in Bengaluru forces many women garment workers—including single parents and sole earners—to depend on PF withdrawals to meet immediate emergencies, healthcare expenses, children’s education, and loan repayments. The new restrictions on withdrawing the full PF balance make it more challenging for them to manage these expenses. Munnade has been holding discussions with 200 worker leaders to explain the structural importance of long-term PF savings while acknowledging the harsh economic realities workers face daily.

Daunting documentation presents another major challenge for workers. Limited education, language barriers, and inability to use technology pose obstacles in accessing PF claims via mobile phones. Migrant workers from other states working in Karnataka face an additional layer of difficulty due to systemic isolation; their families back home are unaware of PF and claim processes, which becomes catastrophic if the earning member passes away in Karnataka, said Fr Sameer Minj, SJ, Head of the Labour Migration Unit at the Migrants Assistance and Information Network (MAIN), Indian Social Institute.

Help desks on Sundays

Mr Rai noted that PF claims are now settled within five to seven days. The technology in the process is continuously updated. In addition to Nidhi Aapke Nikat (NAN) camps, he assured workers that dedicated help desks would be set up for assistance with applications. These desks will be staffed by multilingual staff, operate at the workplace, and will be organized on Sundays to enable workers’ attendance without losing wages. Regarding problems with accessing PF, workers have been urged to flag them on social media platforms such as X or Facebook, which the Central government monitors directly.

(Author: Renuka Phadnis is currently pursuing a PhD in Media Studies at the College of Journalism and Mass Communication, Dayananda Sagar University, and previously worked as a journalist and an Associate Professor)