Both the Supreme Court and Election Commission have recently set “before the next parliamentary election” as the outer timeline for disposing of the pending appeals against exclusion from electoral roll in the appellate Tribunals working in West Bengal. The timetable looks over, indeed buries, the elemental axioms of democratic elections. With a wavering electoral roll and contested disenfranchisement of lakhs of prospective electorate, the Election Commission has set one unprecedented oddity in the India’s democratic trajectory
During the hearing of the PIL of Prasenjit Bose on 25 August 2026, the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant has observed; the appeals in the appellate Tribunals (formed in West Bengal) need to be adjudicated in a time bound manner; more tribunals may be appointed if need be; and everything is to be sorted out before the next parliamentary election.
Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has also affirmed in his latest presser that complaints over names excluded from electoral rolls of West Bengal during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) would be “110 per cent” resolved before the next Lok Sabha elections.
Two threads transpire. The lingering contestations or pending appeals against exclusion from electoral roll (ER) will surely be considered and resolved. And the proclaimed outer timeline is before the next Lok Sabha election, due on April-May 2029.
One can only emphasise that the assertion comes from the heads of two authoritative constitutional institutions. The Election Commission (EC) has the mandate to conduct free and fair elections upholding the tenets of universality, inclusivity, impartiality, equity and integrity. The Supreme Court is the apex court with the remit of protecting the Indian constitution including fundamental rights. Its role is more decisive and deterministic when it accepts the right to vote as not merely a constitutional right, but a component of fundamental rights as well (Anoop Baranwal vs. Union of India, 2023).
The outer timeline thus set looks over, indeed buries, the elemental axioms of democratic elections and implicitly endorses a wavering electoral roll and contested disenfranchisement of lakhs of electorate. Rather than offering succour to public disquiet and fillip to democratic truism, the timeframe evokes host of procedural and substantive questions.
Will the envisaged procedure and structure be suffice or capable of handing the pending appeals within the time limit? More profound is the question of the moral, political and legal status of elections slated in West Bengal before the next Lok Sabha election? This issue assumes importance when election to at least a few corporations and municipalities of West Bengal are in the offing, possibly in coming December. As the state does not have separate ER for the local bodies–as in a few states–the election is to be conducted only on the basis of post-SIR ER, 2026.
It is strange that rather than considering and addressing the core issue of election with contested disenfranchisement in the first place, the legal and political wrangling is veering on questions which are no less subsequential. The ongoing discourse is akin to missing the wood for the trees. Political parties are participating in election overlooking the engrained democratic deficit or without waging battle cry over election only after final decision on the appeals filed.
The Supreme Court remains fixated with the number of names deleted, number of appeals filed and logged by whom (aggrieved one or by the EC), the tribunal’s disposal rate of appeals, the number of constituencies where the winning margin is less than the total deleted voters and whether or not election petitions has been filed in such constituencies. And now on expediting the resolution of appeals.
The judiciary also seems obsessed with managerial interventions rather than arresting abnegation of the right to vote. However, intriguing is the averment of Justice Joymalya Bagchi (on April 1, 2026) that ‘if someone could not vote in this assembly election, it did not mean the right was being denied forever’.
Lakhs of prospective electorate were left in the lurch on ground of ‘egregious’ logical discrepancies and those were shunted out of assembly election, 2026. Does not the suspended animation for massive number of potential electorate imply downright abnegation of their fundamental right and trample the very keystone of representative democracy? Can such an election be democratic and legitimate and does the outcome of the election represent collective public mandate?
Why did not the 2026 assembly election– and now the civic elections– held only after adjudicating or resolving the pending appeals? What prevented the EC from following the preceding ER, as stipulated by Section 21(2b) of the Representation of the People Act? The unequivocal issue is whether any veritable election can be held with volatile ER and without deciding the final fate of lakhs of prospective electorate.
Has any democratic election ever held either in India or elsewhere with one wavering or indeterminate ER and can such an election be legally and morally tenable? After all, following judicial directive, incremental additions to ER were made even two days before polling dates.
Cleansing of ER either through normal or special revision is undoubtedly imperative. When deletion of names from the ER remains uncontested, it is cut and dry case and the expulsion stands vindicated. But whenever the omission is contested through legal recourse, the situation turns equivocal. The uncontested and contested deletions are of different genre; the former is absolutely extinguished and the later seeks supposedly rightful entry. The challengers believe that the expulsion is unfounded and they have some reasonable ground, the validity of which is to be ascertained following legal and documentation protocols.
Though the EC has not disclosed the total number of appeals filed and their disposal rate in the public domain, the RTI reply from the Chief Electoral Officer, West Bengal, and EC’s submission in the Supreme Court reveal that out of total 3810620 appeals, only 82782 (2.2 per cent) cases have been disposed of by the tribunals as on 07. 8. 2026. More decisively 75443 (91 per cent) people have been added back to the ER.
Source; Reworked from Chatterjee Arna, Bar & Bench, 27 Aug 2026
Another bizarre eventuality is that after scrutiny by the 700 judicial officials, 27, 28500 voters were recorded as ‘not eligible’. Yet, 38, 10620 appeals were filed in the tribunals– a difference of 10,82,120 appeals. 7 lakh out of total 27 lakh deleted electors have filed appeals for inclusion of names. The rest of the appeals have been filed against inclusion of those voters who had already been cleared by the judicial officers. Those appeals for exclusion were lodged by the EC and indeterminate individual objectors. Besides the obvious motive of overstraining the work of the tribunals, the gut issue relates to the legality of the EC to be an appellant for exclusion of names.
The disposal rate of pending appeals is trifling little. After six month, only 2.2 per cent of appeals have been disposed of (82782 of 38, 10620). At district levels, more than 20 per cent disposal rate is observed in only Hoogly, Purulia and Bankura. One cannot thus guess the possible timeline for completion of the adjudication process. At the present annual rate of 5 per cent, it will be not less than 20 years.
The appellate tribunals are letting in overwhelming number of individuals in the ER. The restorations affirm that thousands were ousted for unsubstantiated ground or injudicious reason and those persons were debarred from exercising franchise in the assembly election only for the slip of the institution responsible for the revision exercise.
The EC has decreed final ER without completing intrinsic nitty-gritty of the revision exercise that left a whooping proportion of prospective electors in the lurch and then held assembly election discounting ingrained disenfranchisement. And the oddity will continue in the forthcoming civic election in West Bengal. Such eventuality is unprecedented in the Indian electoral history and arguably one unique offering of the EC to the democratic trajectory.
It is surprising that almost everyone including judiciary seems stoical or impervious to the election being held with ever expansive ER and entrenched disenfranchisement of huge number of appellants. Democratic postulates enjoin that the timeline for disposal of appeals must have been set well before the 2026 assembly election itself!
(Author: Amal Mandal is a former Associate Professor of Political Science at Tufanganj
College, Cooch Behar, West Bengal)
Mainstream Weekly