US mid-term election results have heartened many not just in the USA but in most parts of the world. The unprecedented rout of the Republicans is seen as a referendum on President Trump’s policies since he ascended to the office of President of USA in January 2025. After initial trepidation, he has become bellicose and is threatening to continue with his policies. On foreign policies he can do so while there may be some check on his powers regarding internal policies.
The diversity of those who have won is remarkable with many firsts. Democrats won historically Republican states like Texas and Iowa. A Muslim from Michigan and an openly gay from New Hampshire will join the Senate. An Indian origin woman is to become the Mayor of Los Angles. A Black woman and a Native American woman will become Governors of Georgia and New Mexico. Many belonging to the left of center, Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and liberal stream will join the legislatures.
Will this swing to liberalism in US politics bring about change for the better for the world and especially the developing world? Within the USA, Trump imposed his will across the nation adversely impacting the military command, the universities, museums, the central bank, national parks, and so on. He played favourites with media and was in denial of climate change. He closed down or downsized important departments of the government. Some changes in all this can be expected. There is likely to be contestation with Trump retaining a substantial MAGA base. Could he act tough externally to divert attention from his internal problems? Or, the turmoil will divert his attention from pursuing his regressive international agenda?
Extracting Concessions Globally
Trump as a transactional businessman has been extracting concessions from the rest of the world by upending the entire global economic and political world order. It is not that what existed was equitable. The OECD nations and the US in particular have used the Bretton Woods institutions to dominate the world order to extract concessions from the developing nations. This has enabled the rich countries to live beyond their means and maintain their high living standards. This is unlikely to change due to the shift in power in the USA from the Republicans to the Democrats.
The developing countries sell their goods and services cheap to the rich nations by exploiting their labour. An average worker in the automobile sector in India earns in a month what a similar worker in the US would earn in an eight hour day. Developing countries like India compete with each other to supply similar products to the rich countries. This requires them to keep their prices low by squeezing the wages - in case of textiles India competes with Bangladesh, Vietnam, China, etc.
The advanced countries supply to the developing world high technology goods and services, where they maintain high margins. Their corporations (MNCs) control the global supply chain and make huge profits. They shift the profits they make from their developing country operations to tax havens – referred to as Base Erosion Profit Shifting (BEPS) – and by using transfer pricing.
The problem is compounded by cuts in direct taxes - called ‘race to the bottom’. Due to the rapidity with which capital can move, it is able to extract concessions from nations. It threatens to go where taxes are lower. So nations compete in giving it concessions. This reduces availability of resources for public services and that impacts the worker’s standard of living. All these factors have resulted in the rise of profit share in national income at the expense of wages. This has aggravated inequality and resulted in tendency towards shortage of demand and stagnation and periodic crisis, like the financial crisis in 2007-09.
Capitalism Baring its Raw Face
Capitalism started displaying its raw face from the mid-1970s with the decline of Soviet Union and China’s 180 degree turn in its economic policies. More and more countries have had to seek adjustment from International Finance Capital via its institutions, the IMF and the World Bank. What was called ‘Aid’ prior to 1991 was replaced by capital movements that required giving concessions to capital. The world and especially the developing world started to be governed by the ‘Washington Consensus’.
Discussions on creation of WTO started in 1987 in the Uruguay round of negotiations of GATT and WTO came into being in 1995. The developing countries were told ‘to take it or leave it’ and were left with no choice. This opened up the economies of the world. The export and import share of GDP rose. For India this ratio was around 6-8% of GDP in 1991 and it rose to 24% by 2008. Globalization took the form of marketization. Economies became highly dependent on trade and capital flows dominated by International Finance Capital and had to pursue policies dictated by them – national sovereignty has been truncated at the cost of interest of the marginalized sections.
The advanced countries like the USA did not anticipate that jobs in intermediate technology goods would shift to the developing countries where wages were much lower. Production of aluminum, steel, automobiles, etc., moved out leading to the rust belt in the US. In his election campaigns Trump has accused India and China of stealing the good jobs. He promised blue collar workers, young people, etc., that he would bring back the jobs and got their support in the 2024 elections.
Hare Brained Response
Trump’s recipe for bringing back jobs was to raise tariffs on cheap imports from other countries. On April 2, 2025, Trump announced ‘Liberation Day’ tariffs, calling them ‘reciprocal tariffs’ – giving them a veneer of justice. But, these tariffs were ‘protectionist’, designed to raise the prices of imports so that production of tariffed items could be revived in the USA.
This was hare-brained. One way or the other prices would rise in the US. Exporters to the US reduced prices (by cutting margins) to compete with each other but the full impact of the increased tariffs could not be nullified. Even at the higher tariffs, the US cannot produce the imported goods at the price at which the developing countries could supply them, given the wage differentials. So, whether imported or produced in the USA, prices were set to rise.
Trump has used tariffs to extract concessions from other nations, including its closest ally Canada. He replaced multilateralism with bilateralism when he said he will 90 deals in 90 days. Other nations adopted a ‘beggar thy neighbour policy’ hoping to get better terms than others. But everyone lost. EU, Japan and Korea were told that they have to levy zero tariff on US exports while the US will levy 15% tariff on their exports. India and Brazil faced 50% tariff. Trump is forcing US allies to invest hundreds of billions of dollars in the US. The Arab countries have promised to invest a few trillion dollars in the US. Ambani, Adani and Essar have lined up to make big investment in the USA. Along with the massive investment in AI/SI, rise in production of armament for war and supply to war theaters, the US economy has boomed rather than slowed down.
Trump has acted against migration into USA. According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), over 2.5 million individuals have either been thrown out or have voluntarily left. Indian workers are facing problems with H1B visa, etc. Many migrants stopped going to work lest they be arrested. So, employment figures in the US have looked good. But with cheap labour out, prices of food items have risen. They have also been impacted by increase in energy prices and adverse weather.
The wars in W. Asia and the continuing war in Ukraine have disturbed global supply chains and led to price increases globally. Even though the USA is the largest producer of petro products, it has witnessed a steep rise in prices of these products. This has upset family budgets in the USA. Trump had promised to bring down prices and end wars, etc. He has done the opposite and the public reacted to that and voted against his party candidates.
Global Assertion of Power
The continuing wars, undermining of multilateralism, imposition of one-sided conditions on allies, capture of Venezuela’s President and sanctions on Cuba are an assertion of US power. This muscle flexing is due to the raw face of capitalism having unanticipated consequences for US itself.
China’s dramatic rise in the last 30 years was also unanticipated. US regrets helping China’s rise. US Dy. Secy. of State said earlier this year that the US will not make the same mistake with India. Trump since his first term and President Biden have tried unsuccessfully to put roadblocks in China’s way. Now Trump has been forced to treat President Xi of China as an equal and increasingly there is talk of G2.
China using the One Belt One Road (OBOR) initiative has penetrated world markets. It is running a trade surplus of over a trillion dollars. Cleverly, it has diversified its trade and reduced holdings of US dollars to forestall US acting against it. Central Banks globally are holding much more of gold than dollars since US is seen to be unreliable. This has driven up gold prices.
In brief, the US got the world markets opened up as a key feature of the raw face of capitalism, hoping to dominate the world and extract concessions from other nations. This has boomeranged and put the US on the defensive. Trump has tried to tackle it through tariffs, wars and assertions.
What will change?
What Trump thought was the solution to the crisis brewing in the US due to unmitigated rise of capitalism leading to unemployment, price rise, inequality, etc., became the problem. He thought the problem could be taken care of by brute force and he went out of line. He antagonized his recently acquired support base among the young, Hispanics, blacks and so on. He upset nations that have been US allies. The liberals in the US benefitted and won the mid-term elections.
So, temporarily, the forced pace of raw capitalism would slow down but the trajectory is unlikely to change. History proceeds with fits and starts and not linearly. The raw face of capitalism is there to stay. Democrats may check high tariffs, support health insurance and want to reduce tax concessions to the rich but they would want to bring jobs back. Democrats supported the 301 tariffs on nations importing Russian crude. On migration, the Democrats may continue with Trump’s policies though less stridently.
Democrats will go after Trump for the many excesses he and his team have committed. Now with majority in both houses of Congress, they plan to open investigation into his cronyism and corruption by those around him, including his family members. So, Trump will get embroiled in internal politics and firefighting. Many Republicans who till now were afraid of antagonizing him now see him as a liability and may not back him in the Congress. They have to look ahead to the 2028 elections and would want policies that led to their rout to be reversed. But, Trump retains a substantial MAGA base. So, US is deeply divided on issues like migration and change will be slow.
Globally, Trump will be seen to have weakened. So nations will resist Trump’s assertions. Canada and China have shown the way by standing firm against his bullying. Some nations may wait it out for 2028 when Trump will be gone. But the raw face of capitalism will persist since there is no alternative. An end to the wars could ease supply bottlenecks and pressures on prices. It will reduce uncertainty and stabilize the currently volatile financial markets.
Of late, the US has found another way to dominate other nations – its massive lead in AI. Record amount of investment is being poured into this technology. Democrats say they will regulate it and not allow so many data centers to come up. That might slow down advances in AI.
Even if AI development slows down in the US, it will remain the leader in this field and it will continue to use it to dominate the world – in military, in research, in medicine, in efficient production and so on. The switching off of lights in Venezuela and making its radars non-functional and taking control of street cameras in Tehran to eliminate Iranian leadership are examples of the threat US poses militarily. As AI gets embedded in more and more activities, the surplus will accrue to the companies controlling the AI and most of them belong to the US. Just as the social media platforms now belong to companies originating in US and China and they are becoming hugely rich. Democrats’ victory will not change any of this.
Experience over the last many decades suggests whether Democrats are in power in the USA or Republicans that only makes some difference in the US but hardly matters for the world. Democrats are not socialists with an alternative model of development. In the US, liberals are called socialists which they are not and they only want a less strident model of capitalism than the Right wingers. This is of little help to the marginalized in the world or to the developing countries.
Conclusion
Republicans rout in the mid-term elections will bring about changes in US but globally, the raw face of capital will continue to manifest itself. The rising exploitation it fosters has aggravated global over production and problems for US workers and its economy. Trump’s solution to make capitalism more aggressively exploitative has boomeranged for now. While Democrats may soften Trump’s extreme policies internally his actions towards the rest of the world would hardly change. The Iran war may peter out but Democrats do not have an alternative global world order to propose.
The unraveling of the raw face of capitalism since the 1980s will persist even if the pace slows down due to the US mid-term election results. The trajectory would be unchanged, especially with advancements in AI or SI as Trump calls it.
(Author: Arun Kumar, Retd. Prof of Economics, JNU, New Delhi; Author of ‘Indian Economy’s Greatest Crisis: Impact of the Coronavirus and the Road Ahead.’ 2020)
Mainstream Weekly