Mainstream Weekly

Home > Archives (2006 on) > 2012 > In Gujarat What You See is not
 What You Get

Mainstream, VOL L, No 37, September 1, 2012

In Gujarat What You See is not
 What You Get

Sunday 2 September 2012, by Badri Raina

This is a story that beggars belief, and puts into the shade everything we have thus far known of Narendra Modi’s prowess at chicanery and subterfuge.

Indeed, had a report on this not appeared in so impeccable a daily as The Hindu, even my first instinct might have been to say “surely, this can’t be.”

Let me cite in extenso from the write-up authored by the reputed Manas Dasgupta, in the issue of August 13:

“Talking to journalists here, Mr Patel (once the redoubtable Chief Minister of Gujarat, and scion of the puissant Patel community, now fallen out of the BJP, and head of the new Gujarat Parivartan Party) and Mr Mehta (Suresh Mehta, another erstwhile Chief Minister, equally disaffected with Modi and the BJP and partnering Patel in the new party) alleged that several thousand Muslims who greeted Mr Modi during the fasts (reference to Modi’s motley ‘Sadbhavna’ campaign some months ago in ostensible pursuit of social harmony) were in fact Hindus.” Emphasis added.

Lest you think this a piece of disingenuous verbal engineering without basis of any sort in evidence, here is the stunning bit:

“Mr Mehta said that through a Right to Information plea he had got the reply that on the direction of Mr Modi, the Navsasri District Collector had purchased 28,000 skull caps, used by Muslims, and distributed them among BJP workers. He said the BJP workers wearing the skull caps and dressed as Muslims had thronged the ‘Sadbhavna’ venue.” Emphasis added.

Need one add any sort of gloss to the meaning of this story?

I have looked closely at subsequent editions of The Hindu and have not found any repudiation of the report, or the least disclaimer. Conclusion: Manas Dasgupta knew what he was talking about. And kudos to the Collector of Navsari who has had the courage and integrity to say it like it is. Yet another Gujarati braveheart.
At a time when “corruption” is so much a part of “civil society” angst and discourse in India, with campaigns led by the likes of Anna Hazare and Baba Ramdev, both Modi admirers, one might ask whether this despicable fancy-dress transmogrification of identities referred to in the story comprises corruption more corrupt than anything we have known, or whether this ought to be lauded as a piece of transcendant maya authored by god himself.

To think that the authoriser (“on the direction of Modi,” says the RTI reply) of such a cynical, and perhaps criminal, sleight-of-hand, as reported above, should be the BJP’s preferred candidate for the country’s highest executive office! Hindutva at its most creatively unethical yet?

What does seem intriguing, though, is the fact that three whole days since the report appeared in The Hindu (August 13) not a squeak seems on the cards from any media outlet or public platform. Even after one concedes the reality that a majority of India’s electronic channels are Modi acolytes in line with overt and covert corporate interests, the deafening silence thus far seems to tell its own story as well. 

In the meanwhile, it is hard to say how much of this was known to those vested Muslim groups in Gujarat who have been advocating the desirability of rapprochement with Modi. Ah, the lures of commerce. But now that the cat is out of the bag, it may be harder for the Sangh Parivar to fast forward the interested untruth that Muslims are not only so happy in Gujarat but are waiting to go over in droves to Modi, come the State elections this year. Just as the revelation must also have its own fallout among the electorate in other parts of India, Bihar included.
The most important speculation must be whether this latest of Modi’s reported shena-nigans dents the awed loyalty that his support base among well-meaning, piety-ridden Gujarati bhadralok (educated middle classes) bear to him. After all, even they may rethink their position about someone whom they have so venerated, but who is now reported to have stooped so crassly low.
If not, then god alone may help Gujarat.

(Courtesy: Z Net)

Notice: A national lockdown underway in India due to the Corona Virus crisis. Our print edition is interrupted & only an online edition is appearing.