DUTA Letter to the Vice Chancellor any action against Dr. G.N. Saibaba should await the final decision of the Hon’ble High Court | April 6, 2021

DELHI UNIVERSITY TEACHERS’ ASSOCIATION
DAY CENTRE BUILDING, CHHATRA MARG, UNIVERSITY OF DELHI, DELHI-110007 : 27667822, 27666351, 27667725/1697
Website: duta-du.info, Email: duta.du@gmail.com

6.4.2021

Vice-Chancellor (Acting)
University of Delhi
Delhi – 110007
Prof. P C Joshi

Sub: Appeal to review disciplinary action against Dr. G. N. Saibaba, Assistant Professor, RLA College, University of Delhi

Ref: Our earlier appeal dated 3.7.2018

Dear Prof. Joshi,

1. As you may be aware, our colleague Dr G.N Saibaba (Assistant Professor, Department of English, Ram Lal Anand College, University of Delhi), was arrested in the year 2014 by the Maharashtra Police and was kept in Nagpur Central Jail as under trial prisoner for 14 months. Later, he got bail from Mumbai High Court and also from the Supreme Court. Subsequently, in March 2017, he was given life sentence by Gadchiroli Sessions Court and sent to Nagpur Central Jail. Dr G.N. Saibaba is completely paralysed with 95% physical disability from childhood and bound to a wheelchair.

2. Thereafter, his appeal against the judgment and sentence has been admitted in the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court (please find attached copy of order of Hon’ble High Court dated 5.4.2017 as Annexure 1), and the date for hearing is awaited. Dr Saibaba’s wife, Smt. A. S. Vasantha, had submitted a representation to the DUTA stating that there is a very strong likelihood that the High Court acquits Dr. G.N. Saibaba given the flimsiness of the charges and the nature of the evidence against him. The DUTA had attached this representation in its appeal to the then Vice Chancellor dated 3.7.2018, attached as Annexure 2. A copy of the letter dated 14.9.2017 (Annexure 3) submitted to the Principal of RLA in this regard by the RLA Staff Association was also attached to our appeal.

3. In the meantime, the College Governing Body had constituted a four- member enquiry committee from within the Governing Body, and began proceedings towards terminating Dr Saibaba’s services. Much correspondence was exchanged between Smt A.S Vasantha and RLA College, the last few exchanges being attached as Annexures 4,5,6 and 7.

4. On 26.6.2019, the Dy Registrar, Shri S.K.Dogra, wrote to the Chairman, Governing Body, RLA College, via letter no CS-SDC/149/2019/724 as follows:
a. “I am directed to inform you that as per the advice of the Legal Council of the University of Delhi on the subject cited above, the College is requested to send another Show Cause Notice to the charged teacher Dr G.N. Saibaba for the quantum of punishment to be imposed by the Governing Body of the College. A copy of the
email of Legal Council is enclosed for your ready reference.”

5. A copy of this letter is attached as Annexure F to the letter from RLA College to Dr G N Saibaba dated 3.9.2020 (Annexure 4).

6. In the last letter written by Smt Vasantha to RLA College dated 28.11.2020 (Annexure 7), she had explained that due to Covid lockdown jail visits to Dr Saibaba were extremely restricted, as a result of which and also because of his ill-health, no instructions could be taken from him regarding response to the last show-cause notice. No reply to this letter was received by Smt Vasantha from RLA College.

7. On 1.4.2021, Smt Vasantha received a Memorandum and a letter addressed to Dr G N Saibaba dated 31.3.2021 from the Principal RLA College, stating that Dr Saibaba’s services had been terminated w.e.f. 31.3.2021. Copies of the Memorandum and letter are attached as Annexure 8A and 8B.

8. This letter came as a shock since the decision of termination seems to have been taken without even waiting for the reply of Dr Saibaba to the showcause notice served on him by the college on the instruction of the University conveyed vide letter dated 26.6.2019.

9. If the University has approved of the decision of the Governing Body, it seems to be in contradiction to its own explicit instruction of issuing fresh show cause notice to Dr Saibaba. Once the show cause was issued, the college should have waited for the reply before taking adverse action in the matter. The decision to terminate his services without waiting for his reply, when he is unable to respond because of prison lockdown conditions and extreme ill-health (that includes testing positive for Covid along with other life-threatening ailments) seems arbitrary, vindictive and against the principles of natural justice.

10. We wish to re-iterate that since Dr Saibaba’s appeal before the High Court has been admitted and listed for hearing, the matter is sub judice and the original proceedings are continuing, the case against him cannot be regarded as final until all appellate remedies are exhausted. We, therefore, request you once again to review and withdraw any action taken against Dr G. N. Saibaba and not to take any further action against him until his appeal is heard and decided.

11. It is pertinent to note that at the time of his initial suspension, and even subsequently, the Ram Lal Anand College or its Governing Body never made out a case for disciplinary action against Dr. G.N. Saibaba independent of the criminal case filed by Maharashtra Police against him. Throughout the pendency of the case against him as well as the time that he was under incarceration as an under trial or on bail, the college did not have any case of disciplinary action against him.

12. Please also note that in case of Dr. S.A.R Geelani, Associate Professor, Zakir Husain College (E), Delhi University, who was an accused in the Parliament attack case in 2001, Dr. Geelani was suspended after his arrested in the Parliament attack case and his services were not terminated despite conviction and award of death penalty by the Trial Court. He remained under suspension and was reinstated upon his acquittal by the Hon’ble High Court. It is submitted that, similarly, any action against Dr. G.N. Saibaba should await the final decision of the Hon’ble High Court in the matter of his appeal.

With regards, Sd./
Rajib Ray
President

66, Manav Vihar, Sec-15 Rohini, Delhi – 110089 rajibjaya@yahoo.com M: 9868169879
Vice President
Alok Ranjan Pandey
WJ-250 B, Inderpuri
Delhi - 110012 alok.pandey76@yahoo.com Mob: 9540572211
Secretary
Rajinder Singh
WZ-21, Plot No. 15 UFF
St. No. 1 Ravi Nagar Tilak Nagar, Delhi - 110018 rajindersingh.du@rediffmail. com
M: 9711375578
Joint Secretary
Prem Chand
Plot No. 21 T/F
Pocket A-2, Indraprastha Enclave
Sector 17, Dwarka
New Delhi - 110078 prembarvar@gmail.com M: 9868748848
Treasurer
Abha Dev Habib
142, SFS Flats
Mukherjee Nagar
Delhi - 11000 abhadevhabib@gmail.com M: 9818383074

Annexures:
1. Copy of Hon’ble High Court order dated 5.4.2017.
2. Copy of representation to VC by DUTA dated 3.7.2018.
3. Copy of letter dated 14.9.2017 given by Staff Association RLA to Principal
4. Copy of letter from RLA College to Dr G N. Saibaba dated 3.9.2020
5. Copy of reply from Smt Vasantha to RLA College dated 21.9.2021
6. Copy of response from RLA College to Smt Vasantha w/o Dr G N Saibaba dated 10.11.2020
7. Copy of reply from Smt Vasantha to RLA College dated 28.11.2020
8A. Copy of memorandum from RLA College dated 31.3.2021 received by Smt Vasantha
8B. Copy of letter from RLA College dated 31.3.2021 addressed to Dr G N Saibaba received by Smt Vasantha.