How Much of a Democracy is India, Really? | P. B. Sawant

Abraham Lincoln defined Democratic Government as a government of, for and by the people. This definition was true to the spirit of the origin of democracy in the ancient Greek city states, where all males above 18 years were participating in the day to day affairs of the government. The essence of democracy is the participation of the people in the day to day affairs of the state. Mere elections are not democracy. The elections become necessary when on account of large populations people have to govern the state through their elected representatives. However, the sovereignty always vests in the people and they can exercise their powers directly inspite of their elected representatives.

For participation in the governance, the citizen has to be equipped atleast with the basic human rights such as, the right to live without fear or insecurity, right to employment and adequate standard of living, right to enough free education, right to free health services and right to clean and decent environment. The present capitalist economic system cannot be expected to provide these basic human rights to every citizen. Under capitalism, it is the few entrepreneurs who use the national resources to run the industries and business, for their own profits and not for the benefit of the people. What is more, the capitalist system necessarily concentrates the wealth in few hands. The history of capitalism shows that in no country so far, there has been full employment or, social and economic equality. Nor does the system claim to provide every citizen with the basic human rights, including employment. This means that not all citizens are in a position to effectively participate in the day to day governance of the country. At present only 8 families owning giant multinationals possess half of the world’s wealth. In this country, only a handful of families own half of the resources of the country, with 85% of our population living below the poverty line. In other words, the vast majority of the citizens cannot participate in the day to day governance of the country. How can therefore one say, that we have democracy in the country ?
The primary task of any democratic government is therefore to provide the minimum basic human rights to every citizen. In other words, if democracy is to be real, the country must have a rational, planned and scientific economic order which will ensure first and foremost the empowerment of every citizen by providing them with the basic human rights.

The next requisite for a democracy is to have social and economic equality and in any case, the least possible inequality. In capitalist economic order, we cannot expect such equality. The result is that in every democracy so called, where there is capitalist economic system, there is no democracy. Instead we have the oligarchy of the few.
The next and equally important requisite for democracy is to have non-discrimination between citizens on any ground, whether cast, race, region, religion, language or gender. Therefore secularism is implicit in a democracy. Those who don’t believe in equality and non-discrimination are therefore not democrats.

Since every citizen has to be provided with basic human rights, a democratic government is supposed to take initiative to do so. It is therefore, the function of a democratic government to undertake enterprises which will provide employment with a decent standard of living, shelter, education and health service to all. Those who claim that the government has no business to do business, live in the 16th century. A democratic government is not a government for maintaining only law and order and collecting revenue. That can be done by police and revenue officials. It does not require elected representatives to do it.

Pune, December, 24 2020

(Justice P. B. Sawant (Retd.), is former Judge Supreme Court of India and former Chairman, Press Council of India)